What is a stock buyback? How share repurchases work, with the Berkshire example

What is a stock buyback? How share repurchases work, with the Berkshire example

A stock buyback, also called a share repurchase, is when a company uses its own cash to buy back its shares from the market. Those shares are then cancelled or held as treasury stock, so fewer shares remain in circulation. This guide explains why companies do it, how it affects earnings per share, and what to look at when you read about one.

Buybacks are in the news. Berkshire Hathaway repurchased $9.6bn of its own stock in the third quarter and about $2bn more in October, according to Business Insurance, and we looked at that figure in our Berkshire 13F preview.

Why do companies buy back their own shares?

There are several common reasons.

  • Returning cash to shareholders. A buyback is an alternative to paying a dividend. Instead of sending cash to every investor, the company buys shares from those who want to sell.
  • Supporting earnings per share. With fewer shares outstanding, the same profit is divided among fewer shares, which raises earnings per share (EPS), even if total profit is flat.
  • Signalling confidence. Management may believe the shares are undervalued, and a buyback is one way to show it.
  • Offsetting dilution. Companies that issue shares to staff as pay often buy back stock to keep the count steady.

How does a buyback change earnings per share?

Here is an illustrative example with made-up numbers. A company earns $1,000 in profit and has 1,000 shares, so EPS is $1.00. It buys back and cancels 100 shares. Profit is still $1,000, but there are now 900 shares, so EPS is about $1.11, a rise of roughly 11%, with no improvement in the business at all.

That is why analysts distinguish between EPS growth that comes from a better business and EPS growth that comes from a lower share count. It also matters when you read an earnings preview, because consensus EPS often already accounts for expected buybacks.

What does Berkshire’s buyback tell us?

Berkshire’s third-quarter operating profit was $12.71bn, down from $13.49bn a year earlier, and net earnings fell 28% to $22.11bn, per AP coverage and the company’s results. The same coverage says it held about $335.5bn of stocks, including Alphabet, Apple and American Express, at 30 September. The company’s cash figures vary between reports, so we are not quoting one here.

The point for a beginner is the pairing. Berkshire’s profit fell, yet it spent more on repurchases. A buyback shows how management views the price of its own shares, as one source of information, but not proof that the shares are cheap.

What are the risks and criticisms of buybacks?

  • Buying high. Companies can spend billions on shares at inflated prices, destroying value for remaining holders.
  • Debt-funded buybacks. Borrowing to repurchase shares adds risk if earnings fall.
  • Opportunity cost. Cash spent on buybacks could instead fund research, acquisitions or debt reduction.
  • Short-term focus. Critics argue that buybacks can be used to hit EPS targets that decide executive pay.

Defenders say buybacks are a flexible, tax-efficient way to return surplus capital, and that they allow shareholders to choose when to realise gains. Both views can be true in different cases.

How do buybacks affect share prices and the index?

Buybacks create steady demand for a stock, which can support the price. At the index level, large buyback programmes at big US companies are one of the sources of demand cited by strategists when they explain how the market holds up. Our guide on what moves the S&P 500 covers the other forces, including earnings and interest rates. The index level is on our S&P 500 today page.

The share price reaction on the day of an announcement depends on whether it is bigger or smaller than the market expected, not simply on the size.

Frequently asked questions

Is a buyback the same as a dividend?

No. A dividend pays cash to all shareholders. A buyback returns cash only to those who sell, while remaining holders own a larger share of the company.

Does a buyback always raise the share price?

No. It can support the price, but the stock can still fall if earnings disappoint or if the market expected an even larger programme.

What happens to the repurchased shares?

They are either cancelled, which permanently reduces the share count, or held as treasury stock, which the company can reissue later.

Where can I find buyback information?

In company results, in filings with the SEC (10-Q and 10-K reports) and in announcements from the company. See our Guides hub for more explainers.

How can you tell whether a buyback is a good one?

There is no single test, but analysts commonly look at a few things. First, the price paid compared with a reasonable estimate of the company’s value, since repurchases make more sense when shares are cheap than when they are expensive. Second, whether the company funds buybacks from free cash flow or from new borrowing. Third, whether the share count is actually falling, since some companies simply offset the shares they issue to employees and end up with little net reduction.

You can check the last point yourself in a company’s quarterly report, which shows shares outstanding and the amount spent on repurchases. Compare it with the previous quarters to see the trend.

Trade the markets you read about. Open a free WiseProp Trader account, with no deposit.

This article is for education and information only and is not financial advice. Figures are as reported by the sources linked above.

Free daily email
3 things moving markets

The three stories that matter, in your inbox at 07:00. One email a day, unsubscribe any time.

By subscribing you agree to receive the WiseProp Trader News email. We will ask you to confirm first. See our privacy policy.