How do acquisitions affect share prices? Targets, buyers and the Marvell-Lumentum case
When one company agrees to buy another, the target’s share price usually jumps towards the offer price, while the buyer’s shares often fall or stay flat. That pattern is common, not guaranteed, and the size of the move depends on the premium paid, whether the deal is cash or stock, and how likely the deal is to close.
A current example shows both sides. On 2 November Marvell Technology announced an all-stock deal for Lumentum worth about $115 billion including debt, a 23.9% premium to Lumentum’s prior close. Yet Marvell closed down 12.7% and Lumentum fell 18.6%, Yahoo Finance reported. Our full report on the Marvell-Lumentum deal sets out the terms. It is a useful reminder that textbook patterns have exceptions.
Why do target company shares usually rise?
Buyers normally pay a premium to the pre-deal price, because shareholders will not sell at the market price. The target’s shares therefore move up towards the offer. If the news first leaks as a report, the jump can happen before any announcement: Modine rose 28% on a report that Samsung was in talks, which was talk, not a signed deal.
Shares rarely trade exactly at the offer price. The gap between the market price and the deal price is called the spread, and it reflects the chance that the deal fails, the time until closing and the cost of money. A wide spread says the market doubts the deal will complete or expects a long regulatory review. A narrow spread says the market sees closing as near certain.
Why do acquirer shares often fall?
Several reasons stack up. The buyer is paying a premium, so investors ask whether it is overpaying. Paying in stock creates new shares, which dilutes existing holders; The Motley Fool made this point about the Marvell deal in its analysis of the market reaction. Integration is hard, and cost savings often take years to appear. And when a buyer borrows to pay cash, its debt rises.
That does not mean acquirers always fall. If the market believes the target fits the buyer’s strategy and the price is fair, the buyer’s shares can rise. The reaction is an opinion about the price paid and the plan, delivered within hours.
Does it matter whether a deal is paid in cash or shares?
Yes. In a cash deal the target’s value is fixed in dollars, so its share price tracks the offer and is mostly insulated from the buyer’s share price. In a stock deal the target’s holders receive a number of the buyer’s shares, so the value of the offer moves with the buyer’s price. In the Marvell case Lumentum holders receive 4.5 Marvell shares for each of theirs, according to the companies’ SEC filing. When Marvell fell, the offer’s value fell with it, which helps explain why the target dropped instead of rising.
What can go wrong with an acquisition?
- Regulatory block: competition authorities can demand changes or stop a deal. Large deals face longer reviews.
- Shareholder rejection: holders can vote down a deal they think undervalues the company.
- Financing problems: the buyer’s own share price or credit may change before closing.
- Rival bids: a higher offer from another company can lift the target above the first price.
If a deal fails, the target’s shares often drop back towards where they traded before, unless the news has revealed something else about the business.
How does this connect to wider market drivers?
Deal activity depends on share prices, borrowing costs and confidence. When rates rise, as markets expect in the US next month (CNBC reported roughly a 90% chance of a December Fed hike), cash deals cost more to finance. Our guide to what moves the S&P 500 explains how rates and earnings feed into valuations more broadly, and our Companies and Deals section follows live transactions.
Frequently asked questions
Do shares always rise when a company is taken over?
Usually the target rises, but not always. If a deal is paid in the buyer’s shares and the buyer’s price falls sharply, the offer loses value, as with Lumentum. Shares can also fall if investors think the deal will fail or a better offer is unlikely.
What is a takeover premium?
It is the extra amount over the target’s recent share price that the buyer offers. In the Marvell and Lumentum case the companies cited a 23.9% premium to the 28 October close.
What is merger arbitrage?
It is a strategy of buying the target and capturing the spread between market price and deal price if the deal closes. It carries the risk of loss if the deal collapses, and it is practised mainly by professional funds.
Should I buy shares in a takeover target?
That is an individual decision and we do not give advice. Be aware that much of the gain is often captured on the first day, and that a deal can still fail. Read the company’s filings for the terms and conditions.
Trade the markets you read about. Open a free WiseProp Trader account, with no deposit.
This article is for education and information only and is not financial advice. Figures are as reported by the sources linked above.


